Characters highlighted in italics are currently
inactive (if they are listed in black) or are partially inactive (they are
listed in red and italics). This means that they show up once in a
while in play, but are not currently main characters, so it's probably not such
a good idea to try to interact with them on a continuous basis, unless the
player revives them fully! Players listed as inactive have gone on hiatus
from the game, and none of their characters are active.
| Controlling Players | Main Characters | Supporting Characters (ponies) | Supporting Characters (non-ponies) |
| Tallena | Tallena | Ryri (blue male fire lizard) | |
| Nimbus | Lyli (green female fire lizard) | ||
| Rainribbon | Rainribbon/Baby Rainribbon | Rainribbon 2 | Kiri (rainbow female fire lizard) |
| Mermillen | Drummer 2 (male unicorn) | Basalia (Kiri's adopted daughter) | |
| Flame/Baby Flame (inactive) | Racer 2 (male unicorn) | Sliver (small male gas dragon) | |
| Countdown 2 (male unicorn) | Ooze (small male water dragon) | ||
| Glory 2 (female unicorn) | Slethe (male poisonous snake) | ||
| Moondancer 2 (female unicorn) | Spike 2 (pink dragon) | ||
| Petite Gargouille (gatekeeper pony) | Howler (werewolf from the forest) | ||
| Talon (male gryphon) | |||
| Mermillen's father (dragon mage) | |||
| Midnight Sun | Midnight Sun | Destiny (Chance's brother) | Scorch (bronze male fire lizard) |
| Storm | Hope (Chance's sister) | ||
| Dark Sky | |||
| Chance | |||
| Desert Rain | Desert Rain | Krell (bronze male fire lizard) | |
| Desert Rose (dead) | |||
| Dark Firefly (inactive) | Dark Firefly/Lady Firefly | Culath (blue fire lizard) | |
| Mimic | Aariss (green fire lizard with patches of scales that match Mimic's hair) | ||
| Moonjumper (inactive) | Moonjumper | Rorqual | Tinder (flame fairy tails bird) |
| Aquaria | Frost (ice fairy tails bird) | ||
| Starbow | |||
| Black Cat | Black Cat | Stan (used pottery salespony) | Shilling (male cheshire cat) |
| Running Free (Black Cat's cousin) | |||
| Ice (inactive) | Selkie (dead) | Jupiter (pink male summerwing) | |
| Opal | Oracle (leader of pony mages) | ||
| Ice | Zephyr (yellow pegasus mage) | ||
| Windstorm (air elemental dragon pony) | |||
| MLPFreak | Tiny Dancer | Swansong (dancer) | |
| Prism | Stiletto | ||
| Astral Destiny (Adie) | |||
| Roseheart | Sweet Sixteen | ||
| WolvenRangesID (inactive) | Void | ||
| First Kiss | First Kiss | ||
| Jon Dunn (inactive) | Jon Dunn (human) | ||
| ~*~Phoenix~*~ | NightMare | ||
| Baby Tumbleweed | Baby Tumbleweed | ||
| Time Crystal | Time Crystal | ||
| xarcticflamex | Princess SnowFlake (aka Snow) | ||
| Anyone (all players) | Scarab (evil pony) | Black Talon (king of evil dragons) | |
| Claw (evil pony) | Spike (pink dragon) | ||
| Rocky (friendly rock dog from the forest caves) | |||
| Dust Mote (dimwitted dragon, dead) |